The Civil War and the subsequent Reconstruction era brought significant economic and cultural challenges to Goose Creek. Many plantations fell into disrepair, and the architectural landscape of the region began to shift. The economic difficulties led to a decline in the construction of grand homes, with simpler structures becoming more common.

During this period, the architectural style transitioned toward the more modest Victorian era. Houses were typically built with wood frames and featured steeply pitched roofs, decorative gables, and ornate trim. These features not only added aesthetic appeal but also provided practical benefits, such as helping with water runoff in the region’s humid climate.

The roofing materials during this period remained diverse, with wood shingles and tin roofing continuing to be popular choices. Wood shingles were appreciated for their rustic charm, although they required regular maintenance due to the wear and tear from the region's humid conditions. Tin roofing, which had gained popularity in the 19th century, offered greater durability and affordability, making it a practical option for homeowners during the post-war period. Ensuring the maintenance and repair of these roofs became essential, as the region's tropical storms and high humidity could cause considerable damage over time.